An Open Letter To The National Libertarian Party

An Open Letter To The National Libertarian Party

Let’s start from the position that most people already kno (or have at least been exposed to) the litany of libertarian complaints against the various ways in which different levels and branches of government have over-reached their mandate and violated the freedoms of the people. And we can also assume that most people agree that, to some degree or other, the violation of freedom is a negative which should ideally be avoided. No doubt there are some people ignorant of politics, and some who earnestly desire a system of greater control and less liberty, but they are not the audience that needs to be addressed. It’s only those who know and agree more or less on the principles to whom you should appeal. They may think other factors are more important, or they may simply not care enough, or think that their agreement has no consequence on actual government policies. Stop treating these people as though they don’t already know that because their taxes are high, their ability to decide for themselves how to spend significant portions of their own earnings is taken away from them. Or that politicians lie, and the agencies of government frequently make resolving complex problems even more difficult than they would otherwise be. They already understand that perpetual overseas war is fiscally irresponsible and morally repugnant. They already know all that, and they still vote for Republicans or Democrats. Or they stay away and don’t vote at all.
So why don’t these people vote for libertarians? I would say: mostly because they don’t like your chances of winning. For as long as anyone can remember, there have only been two parties that mattered, and if you wanted a chance of your voice and vote having any effect, you were better off trying to change one of the big parties just a little bit then throwing in with the party that best matched your philosophical principles, ideals, and conscience. Who needs a better example than the Tea Party movement, which happened entirely within the greater Republican party system. As a result, many of the most talented and capable libertarian-minded politicians have essentially held their nose and run campaigns on big party tickets and then were subsequently marginalised by losses at the polls, or forced into philosophically awkward policy positions as part of the political reality of policy¬†making in a two-party political environment.
Convincing the libertarian-minded out there that a strong third-party is viable, and let’s start with “viable” before we go aeguing for “necessary”, will obviously require some work. First of all, a competitive Libertarian Party will need an easily communicated general platform which, while philosophically true to the principles of liberty, is no farther from axial-center than the Democrat or Republican platforms, and is sufficiently distinct from them that a unified voice-of-purpose can be used by advocates when communicating to voters (and donors) through public media. Policy advocates must be able to clearly articulate not only the basic theory and principles of libertarianism as a political philosophy, but also be able to accurately convey the precise details of policy laid out in the platform, as well as how they could be enacted without causing unreasonable instability in the institutions which directly impact the lives of millions of Americans.
There is significant turmoil in both of the major parties right now. Populism, religious conservatism, and the established leadership stand at odds over control of the Republican party. Among Democrats, the progressive liberals deal with a rising social justice movement on the far left while they try to sort out after a resounding defeat at the top in the general election. Present the Libertarian party as a reasonable alternative to any voter’s continued support of uncertainty and instability both socially and fiscally. Provide a good solid defense for moderate libertarian policy changes and a stable, reasonable party. Give voters an opportunity to see voting Libertarian as a smart choice, and the Libertarian party could stand a real chance of making a difference in the 2018 midterms.

Jonathan Seid
18 November 2016